As it turns out, Reese Witherspoon was the one to break it off with Jake Gyllenhaal. Reese and Jake have been sharing a house since June of 2008, and while rumors sprouted that the two would eventually marry; in the end it was Reese who got “cold feet” and dumped a “heart-broken” Jake.

FP 1998911 BARM Gyllenhaal Witherspoon 031309 2

more Reese and Jake after the hop…

Hmmmmm. Something just doesn’t seem, er, right about this story. We think there’s probably a much seedier tale, but usmagazine.com is screaming from the mountaintops:

The once-golden couple “fought constantly in the past few months,” and that the relationship concluded over a series of phone calls. No one cheated. There was no drama…She felt pressured to wed again but she wasn’t ready,” an insider says. “She couldn’t give Jake enough and she got cold feet. Jake wanted all of her.”

Hmmmmmm. Likely story. We find it unbelievable that Jake watned “all of her” and Reese found this unsuitable. We’ll be sure to keep you posted on all the nasty details.

Photos: Fame

share save 171 16